Verne Strickland / October 2, 2012
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - A small Chinese company sued President Barack Obama for squashing its wind farm projects that were close to a military training site, saying the president overstepped his bounds and the law, according to court documents made public on Tuesday.
Ralls Corp said when Obama ordered the company last week to divest its projects due to national security risks, he exceeded his power by dictating the terms of the sale, allowing the government to inspect all aspects of its operations and not treating the company equally as required under the law.
The lawsuit comes in the final weeks of the U.S. presidential campaign, during which Obama's Republican rival, Mitt Romney, has accused the president of not pushing back against China's trade and investment practices.
Ralls Corp, which is owned by two Chinese nationals, initially sued the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) in September for ordering the company to temporarily halt operations while the committee completed its probe and made its recommendation to Obama.
The company's chances of winning the lawsuit are slim given the president's broad authority on national security matters.
"It is going to be a tough battle," said Josh Zive, a lawyer with Bracewell & Giuliani who has handled CFIUS cases for 10 years. Zive said the courts tend to stay away from second guessing the executive branch on national security issues. "There is a large amount of discretion given not only to agencies, but in the context of national security, that will make it difficult to win."
Obama issued the rare presidential order on Friday saying there was credible evidence that led him to believe that Ralls Corp and the Chinese Sany Group executives that own the company might take action that poses a risk to U.S. security.
(Reporting By Rachelle Younglai; Editing by Doina Chiacu)
Reuters
| Updated: 10/02/2012 5:47 pm EDT
President Obama
speaks with China’s President Hu
Jintao. Citing national security risks, Obama on Sept. 28,
blocked a Chinese company from owning four wind
farm projects near a Navy base where the U.S. military
flies unmanned drones and electronic-warfare planes
on training missions. (AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster, File)
Jintao. Citing national security risks, Obama on Sept. 28,
blocked a Chinese company from owning four wind
farm projects near a Navy base where the U.S. military
flies unmanned drones and electronic-warfare planes
on training missions. (AP Photo/Carolyn Kaster, File)
WASHINGTON (Reuters) - A small Chinese company sued President Barack Obama for squashing its wind farm projects that were close to a military training site, saying the president overstepped his bounds and the law, according to court documents made public on Tuesday.
Ralls Corp said when Obama ordered the company last week to divest its projects due to national security risks, he exceeded his power by dictating the terms of the sale, allowing the government to inspect all aspects of its operations and not treating the company equally as required under the law.
The lawsuit comes in the final weeks of the U.S. presidential campaign, during which Obama's Republican rival, Mitt Romney, has accused the president of not pushing back against China's trade and investment practices.
Ralls Corp, which is owned by two Chinese nationals, initially sued the Committee on Foreign Investment in the United States (CFIUS) in September for ordering the company to temporarily halt operations while the committee completed its probe and made its recommendation to Obama.
The company's chances of winning the lawsuit are slim given the president's broad authority on national security matters.
"It is going to be a tough battle," said Josh Zive, a lawyer with Bracewell & Giuliani who has handled CFIUS cases for 10 years. Zive said the courts tend to stay away from second guessing the executive branch on national security issues. "There is a large amount of discretion given not only to agencies, but in the context of national security, that will make it difficult to win."
Obama issued the rare presidential order on Friday saying there was credible evidence that led him to believe that Ralls Corp and the Chinese Sany Group executives that own the company might take action that poses a risk to U.S. security.
(Reporting By Rachelle Younglai; Editing by Doina Chiacu)
2
1
5
3
4
The
blades of turbines on a wind farm catch the wind 10 August 2007 in
front of Aegean Sea on Evia island, off the eastern coast of Greece.
Under pressure from the European Union and the terms of the Kyoto
Protocol to cut its current reliance on lignite (brown coal) for energy
production, Greece has green-lighted several wind farm projects since
January. The wind farms are expected to reduce a national energy deficit
that currently forces Greece to import electricity from neighbouring
countries, mainly Bulgaria and the Former Yugoslav Republic of
Macedonia, according to a recent report by the state Regulatory
Authority for Energy (RAE). ARIS MESSINIS/AFP/GettyImages
×
- Contribute to this Story:
- Send us a tip
- Send us a photo or video
- Suggest a correction
From our partners
- Why Is It So Hard For Pandas To Get Pregnant? - Mental Floss
- 2,053 Nuclear Explosions In One Video - Mental Floss
